Blue Point vs. Snap On combo wrench opinions/experiences

[_cy_]

Originally Posted by bwringer

Also, we seem to be discussing a couple of different things. Ratcheting wrenches are NOT a substitute for combination wrenches -- whatever their pedigree, the ratcheting mechanisms can't withstand nearly the same force.

The solution, of course, is to buy both...

have had no problems with generating enough torque with ratcheting wrenches. but when space is really tight... a normal Snap-on box end will fit, but a ratchet box end is too big.

when you have plenty of room, especially with long rusted threads. ratcheting wrenches sure are handy.

got both Blue Point and Snap-on ratcheting wrenches. both work equally well .. Snap-on version has a slightly nicer finish. when buying primarily used, like me... it's really luck of the draw on what comes up for sale.

yes .. you need both... ratcheting wrenches are NOT a replacement for standard box end wrenches.

[slidewayes]

Originally Posted by Tammy

SnapOn

Got to love a gal that rides and buys Snap On

[anotherguy]

Snap-On,Craigslist,Ebay and a tough economy are beneficial to those seeking a bargain on top shelf tools.

[pennswoodsed]

Originally Posted by slidewayes

Got to love a gal that rides and buys Snap On

Must not get banned ,must resist !


That said ,most of what has been said is accurate . blue point ,good tool to use ,snap on best for feel and resale . ratchet wrenches great advance in hand tools, not for tight places,no one I know has broken one. Proto ,Blackhawk have re surged in this market due to Mac ,Stanley connection . Mac very nice tools ,dealers whereabouts currently unknown
Regards,Ed

[KawiVA76]

I'm a tech for Mercedes, have about 8 years in the business. Own a set of flank drive snap on wrenches and a set of ratcheting blue point wrenches. Use the blue points literally every day on almost every job I do. Use the 22mm to turn the head on my oil filter wrench. In eight years the 22 mm needed to have the internals replaced about two years ago under warranty. That is the sole failure and I beat the hell out of these things. You'll be fine with them.

Mike

[concours]

as a side note.... the Flank Drive PLUS combo wrench has nice teeth in the open end. While they may resist rounding off a bit, they tear up fasteners, and I have to be carefull to NOT use them on any motorcycle, let alone my beloved vintage. I would never buy them again.

[_cy_]

Originally Posted by concours

as a side note.... the Flank Drive PLUS combo wrench has nice teeth in the open end. While they may resist rounding off a bit, they tear up fasteners, and I have to be carefull to NOT use them on any motorcycle, let alone my beloved vintage. I would never buy them again.

flank drive plus is just another flavor ... needed on certain applications too tight to allow box end. open end only, where flank drive plus keeps nut from slipping.

I've got both ...

[concours]

Originally Posted by _cy_

flank drive plus is just another flavor ... needed on certain applications too tight to allow box end. open end only, where flank drive plus keeps nut from slipping.

I've got both ...

Um, ah, I know what it's FOR Roto-tilling the fasteners on a customers car may be accepatable at the stealerships.. not in my garage.

[Rd650]

Originally Posted by Rd650 Snapon=Lifetime warranty on hand tools Blue Point= No lifetime warranty on hand tools. Look at the online catalog for country of origin

You have been misinformed , Blue Point has a lifetime warranty just like Snap On .

For a home mechanic , to save some money , Craftsman would be another option .

Good news I have a bunch of Blue Point stuff.

[anotherguy]

I have flank drive + and they're great for removing stubborn fasteners. It's what they're for IMO.

[KawiVA76]

Originally Posted by concours

Um, ah, I know what it's FOR Roto-tilling the fasteners on a customers car may be accepatable at the stealerships.. not in my garage.

Granted plenty of that goes on. Every profession is full of unqualified people. I replace any damaged bolts. For example the steering wheel center bolt that some independent shop apparently decided needed thread lock and about 400 nm. of torque. Took a 24 inch breaker bar and three of us to remove it, lol. The hex corners were starting to raise and crack right before it broke loose. We have 21 guys in our shop. I'm a master tech with 8 years on. I'd say about 7 of us are top notch techs. Another 10 are good guys that are learning and put a good honest days work in. We have four guys that are thieves and hacks. Those types always get caught on their bs at some point. The good dealers boot them, the bad ones lose all of their good techs because they won't put up with it. But it is everywhere in the business to one degree or another.