MOtorrad ADV bike comparo

[Thinc2]

Some interesting data all in one place - weight, HP...

Basic message - they like a lot of these bikes. For the Tenere engine: "unbreakable". For the Stelvio: "very heavy". NOte the price is not lower for the Guzzi and Tenere than the BMW in Germany. Not the case in US.

Overall they acknowledge there are a lot of good bikes competing in this space. They also acknoweldge that what Harley has done for the chopper culture, BMW had done for the GS - you get to belong to a lifestyle when you buy a GS.

They also note that their long term test Ducati has 50K KM's on the clutch with no issues. They have been sourcing this clutch for the last three years from Japanese OEM FCC. And guess what - this is the exact clutch that is in the new GS.

And based on just this review - the KTM comes in first...

[GB]

Thanks for posting the scans.. too bad I can't read it! Strange that GS doesn't come in first place when it has all green bullets and no red, it is german based Motororra after all.. Interested in hearing what they had to say about the Versys 1000.

[ph0rk]

Originally Posted by GB

Thanks for posting the scans.. too bad I can't read it! Strange that GS doesn't come in first place when it has all green bullets and no red, it is german based Motororra after all.. Interested in hearing what they had to say about the Versys 1000.

They do not appear to like the Tenere.


My crappy translations:

Motorleistung: Motor power, motor output
Fahrleistungen: road/driving performance (hence the wheel in the air)
Assistenzsysteme: Like it sounds, I guess - assist systems. ABS, traction control, etc
Gewicht: weight
Reichweite: range
Ausstattung: equipment/fittings, looks like gauges/trip computer
Preis: price, obviously
Gesamt: I'd guess something like Gestalt, the whole, overall winner.

Someone who did more than spend a week ordering beer in Vienna can probably do better.


Seems like odd stuff to compare based on, I wonder how the scores were weighted.

[Murf2]

What, no Farfegnugen category ?

[ph0rk]

Originally Posted by Murf2

What, no Farfegnugen category ?

I think that is meant to be covered by Fahrleistungen

[oalvarez]

Stelvio last overall...ouchie!

[Thinc2]

Originally Posted by oalvarez

Stelvio last overall...ouchie!

They say: too heavy, and that technically it compares with the older GS generations. Also they say it is easily damaged when dropped.

[GS-A-Day]

Note that on p. 43 (the text in the picture) they say that this report is based on the numbers submitted by the manufacturers and (in the case of KTM and Aprilia) some estimates as well. The actual tests are to follow in March.

[oalvarez]

given their criteria, it makes sense that the Ducati came in first.....good for the guys from Borno Panigale!

[Moronic]

Originally Posted by GS-A-Day

Note that on p. 43 (the text in the picture) they say that this report is based on the numbers submitted by the manufacturers and (in the case of KTM and Aprilia) some estimates as well. The actual tests are to follow in March.

Thank you for that. I was wondering. All the power outputs quoted seem to be as as claimed, at the crank. So they are lining them up, on the numbers. A bit of speculation about how the new KTM and GS will go against the established contenders.

The Stelvio might be a heavy beast, but the quoted weight - 285kg - doesn't sound quite right for the version they have pictured and named, which is the one sold with cast wheels and no extras. And while its tech might look old, it's near the Yam in the power department.

[coast range rider]

If only I understood German so I could see which bike that I want that they don't sell here!

[MANXMAN]

Originally Posted by ph0rk

They do not appear to like the Tenere.


My crappy translations:

Motorleistung: Motor power, motor output
Fahrleistungen: road/driving performance (hence the wheel in the air)
Assistenzsysteme: Like it sounds, I guess - assist systems. ABS, traction control, etc
Gewicht: weight
Reichweite: range
Ausstattung: equipment/fittings, looks like gauges/trip computer
Preis: price, obviously
Gesamt: I'd guess something like Gestalt, the whole, overall winner.

Thanks for that.

Can anyone determine if there is any mention of off road abilities in the Fahrleistungen segment?

[Sock Monkey]

This is a spec sheet comparison, and they even got that wrong (compared weight if a Stelvio NTX but showed standard model).

It is nice to have the specs all in one place, but to declare a "spec sheet" winner seems a bit

-SM

[LowOnFuel]

Originally Posted by oalvarez

given their criteria, it makes sense that the Ducati came in first.....good for the guys from Borno Panigale!

I think it says the KTM came in first, but I might be wrong, again.

[Fishenough]

Warps my brain that what many consider a 'large trailie', an off the shelf dirt bike (KTM 1190), can pull a 10 second quarter mile and hit 150 miles per hour.