ADVrider

Go Back   ADVrider > Riding > Layin' down tracks > GPS 101 - Which GPS For Me
User Name
Password
Register Inmates Photos Site Rules Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Rating: Thread Rating: 11 votes, 5.00 average. Display Modes
Old 07-27-2010, 10:55 AM   #1
_vortex_ OP
snow snow snow :(
 
_vortex_'s Avatar
 
Joined: Jun 2006
Location: Twin Cities, MN
Oddometer: 1,134
DeLorme PN-60 vs Garmin GPSMAP 62st vs ....

Ugh. Decisions, decisions.

I've got the GPS Bug. I want a handheld, and I think I have narrowed it down to essentially 3.

Garmin Oregon 450t
Garmin GPSMAP 62st
DeLorme PN-60

First, I guess I have to decide if I want a touch screen or not. On all other features, the two Garmin's seem identical (compare)

The touch screen is larger... but people complain about it in the sun. I also think I like the idea of not smearing dirty fingers all over the touch screen all the time... so I think I want buttons. But the 62st is way higher priced (WHY? I really dont understand Garmin's marketing) Then there is some question as to how the two Garmin's behave... from what I have read, it seems that the software on the Oregon has many different features than the GPSMAP model... (especially with routes and tracks) which you can only discover from using the device. And folks seem to like the predecessor to the 62st a lot better for off-road behavior. Don't know if that carries through into the new model....

If I decide against the touchscreen.... now the DeLorme comes into play.

It seems like if I am comparing features of the 62st vs the PN-60, the DeLorme wins on available maps, price (big win here), and the all-the-maps-you-want for $30 bucks a year. But the drawbacks are - no free maps available (that I have seen, anyway), and a smaller screen.

It seems like the folks here who have DeLorme models really like them.

Anything else I should consider? I'm going to go try to find them in a store today to get a hands on feel....

Can anyone tell me about the maps that they come with - on the Topo included with the Garmin and the DeLorme - how good are they at roads? Do they have all the roads, down to township gravel? Can they locate places by street address? Or does that require other maps?

Any other feedback appreciated :)
__________________
-vortex
_vortex_ is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-27-2010, 03:40 PM   #2
rwamf
Follow me
 
rwamf's Avatar
 
Joined: Oct 2003
Location: Odessa TX USA
Oddometer: 1,351
The Garmin Topo I had for my 60c you could not auto route, and there was no POI's, plus it was a mess on the screen as the roads were very hard to see from the topo lines.
The Delorme Topo is very usable on the GPS, Better visibility than the Garmins, it also has POI's, is Routable, and you can even add you own routable roads to the maps. The Garmin 62st you have to buy the Street maps for detailed roads with auto routing( and only has 500mb of internal memory so you HAVE to Buy a Micro Sd card, The Delorme comes with the best maps IMO.
Yes the Delorme maps will have very good detail when you load the Maps the unit comes with onto a SD card or into the built in 3.5 gig internal memory ( 16 gig for the SE model), just remember that at a store the unit might only have the world base map on it( only major Hwyways), It will come with Topo NA 9.0 which has topo for the US and Canada and roads for Mexico. It will also come with 4 DVD's with precut maps to load onto the Sd card for the detailed maps you want. You can search by address etc, The routing has been improved over my 40 also.
The screen is smaller than the 62 but the data is better and to me it has not been an issue.
I can only say the the PN60 is a very nice GPS. It's tracking capabilities alone blows the Garmin away. The map subscription is very handy and a good deal. I got mine ( PN60wSE with SPOT) for the same price as the 62st and mine has the SPOT unit, better maps and 16 gig internal memory which really makes it a great deal.
__________________
"Do not go where the path may lead, go instead where there is no path and leave a trail. ~ RWE
Robert

rwamf homepage

rwamf screwed with this post 07-27-2010 at 04:03 PM
rwamf is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-27-2010, 06:21 PM   #3
Countdown
Beastly Adventurer
 
Joined: Oct 2003
Location: Carson City/Ridgecrest
Oddometer: 5,281
Everything Robert said above is good stuff and he has had quite a few.

You did not say what size bike, what you want to do with a GPS, and how much you want to interface with the Internet and other users.

Off-road only, a lot of street also, all street, in car/truck.

Another consideration is software. If you want simple (like my brain) Garmin and Mapsorce is all you need. If you like software (I hate it and even the guys who write it) then there are lots of options for GPS and data management software.
__________________
Jerry Counts
Countdown is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-28-2010, 11:04 AM   #4
_vortex_ OP
snow snow snow :(
 
_vortex_'s Avatar
 
Joined: Jun 2006
Location: Twin Cities, MN
Oddometer: 1,134
Thanks for the info. I went and saw them all at REI last night. On specs, I really thought I would like the DeLorme the best. I wanted to like it the best. But in my hand... I dunno. It feels more awkward to hold. And I really wish the screen was bigger. And the button feel just seemed... cheap.

I was also disappointed by the lack of roads, but I hadn't though of how it may or may not be set up in the store. Thanks, rwamf. So, if I load it up with what it comes with, it would have all of the small roads?

Can you search by address with the Delorme? Because I couldn't figure out how to do it in the store. The best I could find was by city, and even that wouldn't let me type in a city, it was only based on what cities were near my current position (a list). But that was probably a map issue?

By contrast, the 62st felt good in my hand. The buttons worked the way my fingers expected them to. The maps it had loaded in the store were better than what the DeLorme had (as far as roads)... but I have no idea what was loaded. I also couldn't figure out how to enter an address on this unit... I came away thinking that with either of these handhelds, the only way they would work trying to locate an address is to map them out ahead of time with the software, or google maps, and then upload the route. I hope I'm wrong? I don't mind it being frustrating and slow to enter an address, I won't do it often... but I'd like to be able to do it.

That takes me back to the 450t... which I liked a lot more than I thought I would. You can type on the screen... the screen is bigger, and it feels nice in the hand.

But, folks say the reception on it isn't as good... and I don't know the specifics of how the software behaves compared to the other garmin line.

So I still have no clear favorite.

As far as how I want to use it... well, that needs to develop as well. I've never owned a handheld GPS before. Have an older TomTom for the car. First use will be hiking.... but after that, I want to mount it on my DRZ, mostly for the fun of it. Like to be able to find roads, and record tracks, etc... if I ever find time to take another trip. But I don't do serious street riding with it. I'd also like to be able to throw it in my pocket when I'm in a unfamiliar city... since I don't yet have one of those fancy phones :)
__________________
-vortex
_vortex_ is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-28-2010, 11:22 AM   #5
_vortex_ OP
snow snow snow :(
 
_vortex_'s Avatar
 
Joined: Jun 2006
Location: Twin Cities, MN
Oddometer: 1,134
Question

Can anyone tell me... what are the differences between the PN-60W SE and the PN-60?

I thought that the W was for the SPOT... but that isn't true.

The only difference I can see is the 16 GB of memory, vs 3.5.

Is there more? Other than the color?

It also seems like the only place you can get the W SE (without the spot) is DeLorme direct... which makes it about $200 more than I have seen just the PN-60. And I can get a 32 GB SD card for ~80.
__________________
-vortex
_vortex_ is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-28-2010, 11:58 AM   #6
Countdown
Beastly Adventurer
 
Joined: Oct 2003
Location: Carson City/Ridgecrest
Oddometer: 5,281
Quote:
Originally Posted by _vortex_
As far as how I want to use it... well, that needs to develop as well. I've never owned a handheld GPS before. Have an older TomTom for the car. First use will be hiking.... but after that, I want to mount it on my DRZ, mostly for the fun of it. Like to be able to find roads, and record tracks, etc... if I ever find time to take another trip. But I don't do serious street riding with it. I'd also like to be able to throw it in my pocket when I'm in a unfamiliar city... since I don't yet have one of those fancy phones :)
Based on that I would buy a 60/76Cx on blow out sale for about $200 plus City Nav for $80 and get some use under your belt. Probably 80% of the the off-roaders are using these model now and are very happy. Once you know what you may not like about one of these you will know best how to spend some big bucks.
__________________
Jerry Counts
Countdown is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-28-2010, 02:28 PM   #7
rwamf
Follow me
 
rwamf's Avatar
 
Joined: Oct 2003
Location: Odessa TX USA
Oddometer: 1,351
Quote:
Originally Posted by _vortex_
Can anyone tell me... what are the differences between the PN-60W SE and the PN-60?

I thought that the W was for the SPOT... but that isn't true.

The only difference I can see is the 16 GB of memory, vs 3.5.

Is there more? Other than the color?

It also seems like the only place you can get the W SE (without the spot) is DeLorme direct... which makes it about $200 more than I have seen just the PN-60. And I can get a 32 GB SD card for ~80.
The 'W' = Wireless, it can be for communicating with the Spot or with other PN-60w's, You can buy it with or without the Spot, I got my 60wSE with the Spot for $549.
They will have a new feature out this fall that will show you where your buddies are on the map , kinda like the Garmin Rhinos,
The SE is only sold through Delorme and has 16 gig internal memory
Like I said in the earlier Post do not compare maps in the store as the unit will not have any detailed maps in it, you load the ones you want as there is about 20-30 gigs of data for all the NA, So I just loaded the Western US on mine which is about 10 gig, and have about 12 gigs of Aerial Photos on the SD card for areas I want to explore.
As far as searching for addresses? well I have never tried that, I do like the search function as you can hit the search and it will bring up many options for different categories, or you can narrow the search from a drop down menu.
You can input a street name, city, State etc, I just have not used it, in my Car I have a street unit touch screen that works great, so off road I do not or have not found a need for that feature.
__________________
"Do not go where the path may lead, go instead where there is no path and leave a trail. ~ RWE
Robert

rwamf homepage
rwamf is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-28-2010, 02:59 PM   #8
_vortex_ OP
snow snow snow :(
 
_vortex_'s Avatar
 
Joined: Jun 2006
Location: Twin Cities, MN
Oddometer: 1,134
For the price, (as low as $331 for a PN-60, delivered) I just have a hard time considering the Garmin's. Even if I bought one of the last gen models, I would be spending close to the same to get the necessary maps... and as a tech person, it really pains me to spend that kind of money on outdated hardware. Especially when Garmin seems to produce outdated hardware from the beginning :)

And everything I read seems to indicate that the DeLorme data is better.

Anyone have any longevity data on the Garmin vs the DeLorme, when stuck on the buzzy handlebars of a bike like the DRZ?
__________________
-vortex
_vortex_ is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-28-2010, 03:59 PM   #9
rwamf
Follow me
 
rwamf's Avatar
 
Joined: Oct 2003
Location: Odessa TX USA
Oddometer: 1,351
Quote:
Originally Posted by _vortex_
For the price, (as low as $331 for a PN-60, delivered) I just have a hard time considering the Garmin's. Even if I bought one of the last gen models, I would be spending close to the same to get the necessary maps... and as a tech person, it really pains me to spend that kind of money on outdated hardware. Especially when Garmin seems to produce outdated hardware from the beginning :)

And everything I read seems to indicate that the DeLorme data is better.

Anyone have any longevity data on the Garmin vs the DeLorme, when stuck on the buzzy handlebars of a bike like the DRZ?
I quit using my Garmin 60C cause the thing kept shutting off on my thumper, first one was the battery contacts, fixed that then it was the contacts from the battery board to the GPS board, not an easy fix. even quit while on bike power. Garmin replaced it twice and then I just quit using it, Went to a Lowrance H20c, never had a power problem, I bought my PN40 when it first came out a couple years ago because I loved their Topo maps, never a problem with it, to me it is a much better built unit than my Garmin. Now I have the 60 and it is very nice and all my cables, SD cards and Ram mount etc from my 40 work with it.
But buy what ever one you want and try to use it, learn all that it will do. The GPS can be a very handy tool, but there is no perfect GPS, so till then I just use what works for me and right now I like the Delorme Maps the best, and the new 60 is very very nice.
__________________
"Do not go where the path may lead, go instead where there is no path and leave a trail. ~ RWE
Robert

rwamf homepage
rwamf is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-28-2010, 07:39 PM   #10
Countdown
Beastly Adventurer
 
Joined: Oct 2003
Location: Carson City/Ridgecrest
Oddometer: 5,281
Quote:
Originally Posted by rwamf
I quit using my Garmin 60C cause the thing kept shutting off on my thumper, first one was the battery contacts, fixed that then it was the contacts from the battery board to the GPS board, not an easy fix. even quit while on bike power.
Yes the pre "x" 60/76 units had some battery/power problems. Actually I think more from 76 than 60 but both had them. I don't think I have seen any reports of the problem on the "x". Also the new lighter batteries came along about the same time which really helps and most people started hard wiriing them which also helped.
__________________
Jerry Counts
Countdown is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-03-2010, 11:05 AM   #11
wparkinson
Gear Whore
 
wparkinson's Avatar
 
Joined: Dec 2008
Location: Down On the Farm...
Oddometer: 2,075
I am going to have to throw my hat in on the Delorme side..... now I don't have the 60 but I do have the 40....... I love it... It works great for me all the time.

As stated above you have to add the maps to it but it comes with TOPO 9.0 which is an awsome package.

I don't ever carry the GPS in my hand so that really isn't a consideration. I use my 40 in a ram cradle mounted to my handle bars and it works great. I have a USB hard wired into my bike so I can keep it powered all the time. I do have the Li-ion battery in it just in case and it stays nice and charged. The battery isn't the greatest and won't keep a charge long but I usually don't have to worry about it. I do keep extra batteries around just incase but I have a helmet cam too so I have them anyway.


Long and short the PN series in combo with the TOPO USA S/W is a great system and I love mine. I wish I had the $$$ to upgrade to the 60w with the spot. But for now I will keep using the 40.

On the map download..... For the price it is great. I went nuts when I first started....now I really don't use it that much. I have found that the TOPO maps that come TOPO usa are just fine. It is nice to be able to get Sat photos if I want but I just end up using Google Earth to look at... I don't even use them on my GPS anymore.

Anywho... just my two cents worth....

BTW rwamf pretty much covered it all.....
wparkinson is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-04-2010, 04:21 PM   #12
rwamf
Follow me
 
rwamf's Avatar
 
Joined: Oct 2003
Location: Odessa TX USA
Oddometer: 1,351
Here are a few screen shots from the 60w
With and without aerial images, also have draw layers on there, the red and blue are tracks for a ride coming up and the others are tracks saved as a draw layer, as you can see they show up at at farther zoom levels.


Very nice Off-Road GPS
the best I have found so far.
__________________
"Do not go where the path may lead, go instead where there is no path and leave a trail. ~ RWE
Robert

rwamf homepage

rwamf screwed with this post 12-15-2010 at 05:24 PM
rwamf is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-06-2010, 09:57 AM   #13
_vortex_ OP
snow snow snow :(
 
_vortex_'s Avatar
 
Joined: Jun 2006
Location: Twin Cities, MN
Oddometer: 1,134
To update my thread, I ended up getting a DeLorme PN-60. And a RAM mount. And a 32 GB SD card. Everything works great so far. No regrets yet. Though I am discovering that most of my NiMH batteries are... well, not up to the task anymore. Either that, or this thing really eats batteries. But I need to get some new ones before I pass judgement on that.

Maybe after camping next week I will know how to use the entire thing :)

About the only review I can provide so far is that the screen is really crisp and clear. Even outside... in the sun. Easily readable while at road speed.
__________________
-vortex
_vortex_ is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-06-2010, 03:44 PM   #14
Albie
Kool Aid poisoner
 
Albie's Avatar
 
Joined: Mar 2004
Location: NWA
Oddometer: 9,184
Went to REI today and played around with a PN 60 and a GPSMAP 62. Both have very good display's with the 62S having the larger real estate. What really impressed me about the 62S was the speed of the redraw. Now this was with the base maps in mind you, not sure if the Topo's and CN might slow it down a tad. It was faster then the PN 60 for sure though, not to say the PN 60 is slow. On the 62s, the menu showed a selection to prompt before auto recalc on routes, but then my 76x has that option and it doesn't work. Since Garmin has stopped using the SIRF chipsets, I can only assume that the 62s probably has the same fault which added to the external antenna are too very big minuses in my book. Add to the fact that the PN 60 can hold 100 routes and it stores 20000 point tracks, and I'm thinking this is gonna be my next GPS.
Albie is online now   Reply With Quote
Old 08-07-2010, 05:05 PM   #15
JimC
Beastly Adventurer
 
JimC's Avatar
 
Joined: Aug 2003
Location: Sacramento, CA
Oddometer: 1,039
Quote:
Originally Posted by Albie
.........What really impressed me about the 62S was the speed of the redraw. Now this was with the base maps in mind you, not sure if the Topo's and CN might slow it down a tad. It was faster then the PN 60 for sure though, not to say the PN 60 is slow............
rwamf and I have had this ongoing discussion about the Delorme GPS's since they were first released and in my opinion nothing has changed much in the last 5 years or so except the GPS's from both manufacturers have improved significantly.

Here is my take and I have owned every model of Delorme GPS and at least 6 or 8 models of the Garmin handhelds.

Delorme
Without a doubt the best mapping package in the business with the worst PC interface in the business. The track/map drawing capabilities are unmatched. If the most important function of your GPS is to be a catalog of hundreds and hundreds of tracks you save and you need them all loaded on your GPS at one time then the Delorme is the GPS for you. Without a doubt the PN60 is the best of the Delorme GPS’s. If you are going to buy a Delorme do yourself a favor and save up until you can afford the 60, it is worth the extra money. The integrated Spot system is another game changer and the ability to send text messages from the middle of no where for the price of a Spot subscription was unthinkable just a couple of years ago. When it is delivered (and if it works) this functionality will make the Delorme unique in the industry.

Other than the above the Delormes suck when compared to the Garmins. The Find capability and the routing functions are a joke, really. The routing is so bad and so slow that I just don’t use it for anything. I guess if I was in the middle of nowhere with no maps and no local knowledge I would use it but that would be about it.

Garmin
While not the world class mapping package of Delorme, Garmin is not far behind. The new 62/78 GPS’s allow you to store 200 tracks of 10,000 points each which is enough for all but .001% of the ADV riders out there. The Mapsource software is certainly not as powerful as the Delorme Topo Software but I can teach you how to use it in about 3 minutes and you will remember how to use it the next time you go to create a route or a track. I never felt the old 60/76 track handling capabilities were a significant weakness so the new capabilities remove any limitations.

For all other GPS functions the Garmin is superior to the Delorme. The find function, routing, etc., etc. are so much faster and accurate on the Garmins that there is no comparision.

So I guess you can tell where this is headed. As an all around, do it all GPS the new Garmin 62/78 units would be my first choice. They are easy to use, intuitive to operate, lightning fast, have decent, easy to use PC software and now have an ever expanding universe of downloadable maps (both free and for a fee) which means you can use them anywhere in the world.

The Delorme GPS’s are kings of the niches they focus on, outstanding track building software and maps and integrated Spot communications. If these are critical to you than the Delormes are an easy choice.

My personal experience is that 90% of the people on this forum would be happier and better served with a Garmin GPS.

Jim in Sacramento
JimC is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Share

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

.
Display Modes Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


Times are GMT -7.   It's 02:46 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.5
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ADVrider 2011-2014