World of Tanks

[vwboomer]

I too am confused about penn with no damage. it happens with AP rounds more than HE to me. somethi g has to get damaged

[OConnor]

Originally Posted by Mambo Dave

I mean, we're talking ultra-patience in not moving from an area for a good while, like this T30 driver eventually did.

When I do this in the T28 proto or T30 (even when making kills) I get called a camper and have even had dead team-mates give the opposition my coordinates.

[Mambo Dave]

Originally Posted by vwboomer

I too am confused about penn with no damage. it happens with AP rounds more than HE to me. somethi g has to get damaged

Based on some recent reading about tank warfare, AP rounds did occasionally pen and do no appreciable damage. Yes, there was damage to the armor - but nothing was affected beyond adding some unwanted ventilation.

But we have no way of ensuring they did NO damage whatsoever as shooters since, from the guy who got shot's perspective, he may have just had a crew member die, and that ends up bad enough. Without that commander skill for it, we also don't know how many sub-systems were affected by a pen-no-damage shot.

Although I've read suggestions of it, we also have no way to ensure that a no-damage penetration doesn't weaken that area for a susequent shot that may add to crew members killed or damages. For example. it seems to me that I've had shots that weakened, but did not break, my tracks. But sure enough, the next hit by what-ever on that side will track me. So I believe there may be a cumulation of damage count going on with each area of tanks. (I think Iv'e even heard of super-pershing's double-armored fronts being shot up enough that they started letting shots through.)

[Switchblade315]

this was a epic kill.



yes i was alive after the hit but i got shot right after, and i hit him on the other side of that bush.

[timk519]

Originally Posted by Mambo Dave

Are you running hit zone skins, and aiming appropriately?

I was, until 8.2 came out. I was pretty successful to start, usually got 100-200ish damage a hit, and then - nothing. That's what's so puzzling.

Originally Posted by Mambo Dave

I thought that JagdPanther was fine with the 7.5mm, and one of my most successful tanks (121 battles, 74% hit ratio). I probably started carrying a few Gold rounds in it, but those were mainly for high-tiers.

I see your hit-ratio is down around 62% with it, so my guess is either that you're taking very long-distance shots where the pen drops off (and missing some of those long-distance shots), or that you're still working on aiming. You own a few of them, so it's not like you don't know this, but the upgraded tracks, and clutch braking for the driver (have camo trained amongst the rest of the crew), will help spin your non-turreted TD's around faster. I can't remember if the Jagd is one where the tracks need upgraded to load on the bigger guns, but... it does anyway.

This is a relatively new tank to me, so I've been playing it a bit more like it's weaker cousin,which does pretty well at long range. I've also had a number of games where I've hit OPFOR tanks a number of times in the usual places w/no damage. For instance, with the KV5, hitting the washing-machine in front and right of the turret usually gets some good damage. With that tank, a dead-center hit got a "bounce".

Originally Posted by Mambo Dave

Even for distance shots, where the Jagd is good at accuracy, I found I still needed to try to hit a tank going perpendicular to me in the rear engine area, so that meant accounting for his movement and such to try to hit that area. Distance shooting to heavy tanks facing me, frontally, were usually not so great with pen IIRC.

Maybe something did happen to it though - I never rule out War Gaming nerfing German tanks - especially now as a Christmas gift to actual Germans.

LOL.

On the other hand, I just bought a T28, and I'm already getting pretty good results with it after 3 battles:

[Hodag]

should i get spall liner on the amx 40?

i have rammer, vents, and bogey wheels mounted
love that tank
30 hit battles not uncommon

what crew training??

[timk519]

Originally Posted by timk519

I was, until 8.2 came out. I was pretty successful to start, usually got 100-200ish damage a hit, and then - nothing. That's what's so puzzling.

I've since upgraded to the next gun up - MUCH better.

Correction - I was still using the 8.8/36! I double-shotted a tank, and got good pen's on other tanks.

I give up.

[Mambo Dave]

Originally Posted by Hodag

should i get spall liner on the amx 40?

i have rammer, vents, and bogey wheels mounted
love that tank
30 hit battles not uncommon

what crew training??

Are you keeping that AMX 40 long term?!

I mean, sure, I can see a spall liner instead of the wheels since it is so slow, since arty at that level fires so fast, and since you're going to see Hetzers with their HE Derp guns.... but crew skills?

Clutch braking makes the tank turn faster, but I forget how fast that turret turns, or if it even needs clutch braking to help it.

I mean, if it's a serious contender for a keeper tank, then you've got to determine what area you feel it's lacking in. If you hide in bushes a lot and snipe, then camo skills across the board. Play it as a super-tank taking on all comers, then Brothers in Arms for all crew (doesn't take effect until all crew hit 100% with it). Getting tracked a lot, or damaged otherwise? Then repair for all crew.

I know the AMX 40 isn't a fast tank, so perhaps some perks should be ruled out, but I've seen the tank played in different ways, so it's tough to suggest the best perks.

[Hodag]

i like it as a brawler
its fun

i've bought the tank past it already, and will keep it long term

plus i'm ok at playing it, nobody takes an amx 40 seriously

[papalobster]

Originally Posted by Hodag

plus i'm ok at playing it, nobody takes an amx 40 seriously

I know I giggle every time I see one.

[Hodag]

Originally Posted by papalobster

I know I giggle every time I see one.

i average 25 hits a game
what other tank does that??

[Geek]

Originally Posted by Hodag

i average 25 hits a game
what other tank does that??

Churchill III.

There's a reason it holds 140 rounds
(mind you.. the average damage is 75).

[Dismount]

I hated the amx 40 with a passion that bordered on psychotic.

I would huff and puff and waddle up to the battle. Most of the time when I would finally get there the top 2-3 on the enemy team would pop around a corner a foot away.

poof.

[Dismount]

Originally Posted by Mambo Dave

Are you sure they're not "we hit" announcements rather than penetration announcements?

At very least, with penetration and a HE round, multiple crew should be dead. You may not see that come up as damage though.

This is another area that's worth looking into with a friend or two in a training room, but ... I'm not buying a Lee tank ever again.

Nope, they'll holler out Penetration!.... then nothing. I've been running the churchill a lot lately, so flinging plenty of lead. Mediums, heavies, lights, TDs, arty....

doesn't seem to matter which tank I'm shooting at. Or even where. I had one game that reported 25 hits on a kv-1 and a grand total of about 130 damage.

[timk519]

Originally Posted by Dismount

Nope, they'll holler out Penetration!.... then nothing. I've been running the churchill a lot lately, so flinging plenty of lead. Mediums, heavies, lights, TDs, arty....

doesn't seem to matter which tank I'm shooting at. Or even where. I had one game that reported 25 hits on a kv-1 and a grand total of about 130 damage.

at least I'm not the only one with this problem.