Small truck? Maybe a Minivan would be better?

Discussion in 'Shiny Things' started by The PacRat, Nov 3, 2011.

  1. The PacRat

    The PacRat I'm that other guy

    Joined:
    Dec 13, 2007
    Oddometer:
    2,737
    Location:
    the Poison Oak Patch
    It's like I have never paid attention to Minivans in all my life. Like they didn't exist.

    I am considering getting rid of my old Dodge truck and getting a small truck, since I don't really need to haul GIGANTIC loads much anymore. Naturally thought of another small truck. I had a Ranger 4cyl std, and it was a gutless but fun truck that averaged 22mpg. Crap - I almost got 20mpg in my Cummins - what the hell good is a small truck that hauls little, and sputters up hills?

    Then, like a light going off, I thought "what about a minivan"? I'm old, married, and don't care what anyone thinks!

    I have zero experience with or knowledge of them. A few quick searches and I found the Mazda MPV, and a few others.

    What's good? Reliable? good MPGs? How much crap can you jam into one of them? Full size sheet of plywood? I don't really want one of the full size vans. I'd also like carpeting and seating (preferable removable). Saw some pretty damn nice looking MPVs and Town and Countrys. My price range will be about 6-7k - should be able to get something pretty nice for that.

    Tell me about minivans.
    (please) :D
    #1
  2. ragtoplvr

    ragtoplvr Long timer

    Joined:
    Oct 18, 2007
    Oddometer:
    6,723
    Location:
    central USA
    The toughest minivan if well maintained is a Chevy Astro. Had 2, last one was at 187K when the Joplin Tornado ate it. 21 MPG, rear wheel drive so no struts, get the death cool out of it as soon as you get it before it eats the intake gaskets and you will have no issues. I have replaced the gaskets, took about 10 hours if you have done one then it is a 4 hours job or so.

    Change all fluids, all of them, anti freeze, power steering, tranny, rear end, brake fluid, and actuall grease all those 14? grease fitting on the front end on some sort of schedule and it will run forever.

    Pulled my buddies dead Windstar back 2X with mine, once over 1000 miles. In about the same number of miles he did head gaskets, 2 transmissions and one alternator while I did a starter, radiator fan clutch and fuel pressure regulator. He kept saying but mine is 5 star rated. BUT there is a government web site that lists actual crash results and the Astro/Safari was always in the top 10 safest. I hauled my boat, firewood, rock, etc and never a problem.

    Rod

    Rod
    #2
  3. R_W

    R_W wannabe

    Joined:
    May 3, 2005
    Oddometer:
    4,126
    Location:
    Kansas
    A minivan gets low 20's (maybe even high teens) in the real world. At least any more than a couple years old.

    I got a Windstar I would trade even up for your Dodge :deal (don't get a Windstar). None of the front wheel drive minivans have strong transmissions.
    #3
  4. Maggot12

    Maggot12 U'mmmm yeaah!!

    Joined:
    Feb 21, 2010
    Oddometer:
    6,381
    Location:
    Barrie Ont
    They're very popular in most of Canada where most of the US consumers would own trucks. I have an 01 Montana that's been trouble free for the 190k I have on it (knock on wood).

    We've used ours every summer pulling a tent trailer, max tow rating is 3500lbs. 4x8 sheets of plywood/drywall will fit with the doors closed, and I've put 12ft long pieces of baseboard in it as well. I camped/slept in it many times with all but the front seats taken out. The Chyrs models have the stow away seats which is a great feature.
    I took the front wheel off my DRZ400 and had that in the back as well, along with a rolled up 14ft zodiac and a 10hp outboard.

    I'm not a huge fan of the thing but the practically of it is awesome. I see it as a great tool or appliance, if that makes sense. Can easily carry 7 adults, or a couple kids, camping gear and bicycles.

    You should be able to get a 3-4 yr old in your price range and you'll get better mileage than any full sized truck.

    If you don't need the high towing capacity of a PU this is a good alternative.
    #4
  5. The PacRat

    The PacRat I'm that other guy

    Joined:
    Dec 13, 2007
    Oddometer:
    2,737
    Location:
    the Poison Oak Patch
    So far I am looking at the Grand Caravan, the MPV and the Honda Odyssey. I like the idea of easy to stow seating of the Grand Caravan. Sure looks like it will hold a lot of crap!
    #5
  6. Owyhee

    Owyhee Ran when parked

    Joined:
    Oct 29, 2007
    Oddometer:
    564
    Location:
    The Horse Latitudes
    If you don't need lots of room, look into the Mazda5. It's built on the Mazda3 platform and is just a little bigger. It seats six, four adults and two kids, and is even available in a stick (like mine). They're cheap new (~$20,000) and are about as sporty as minivans go. I got my 2006 with 85,000 miles for $11,000 earlier this year.

    Mine gets a solid 22-24mpg around town and averaged 28mpg from Boise to Vegas last weekend.

    -Owyhee
    #6
  7. Jimmy the Heater

    Jimmy the Heater Tilting the Horizon

    Joined:
    Sep 8, 2004
    Oddometer:
    2,153
    Location:
    WA Palouse area
    A word on the stow and go seating on the Mopar vans. Don't put anyone you like in those seats. One of the most uncomfortable seats ever put in a vehicle. To make them fit in the floor I'm pretty sure they removed all padding. Also very flimsy feeling, I get the impression that the seat back would fail in even a small rear end collision.
    That being said we have one without the stow and go and it has 214k on it and the engine has been fantastic. Ate one tranny, had that rebuilt with the updates and its been great ever since. 22-24 mpg and a huge ammt of space. Ninja 250 and 500 have been in there with just the mirrors removed. Drywall fits no problem. Even overnighted in it a couple of times.
    If you don't care about the stigma they are a wonderful transportation appliance.
    #7
  8. AtlantaViking

    AtlantaViking Been here awhile

    Joined:
    Apr 10, 2008
    Oddometer:
    987
    Location:
    Hotlanta
    That Mazda5 has always been a sleeper in my opinion. Not stupid big but big enough to use for weekend chores and looks like it would be fun to drive (for a minivan). I really like the idea of having sliding doors on it too. Cool car...or truck...or whatever it is.
    #8
  9. PaddedHat

    PaddedHat Been here awhile

    Joined:
    Aug 24, 2010
    Oddometer:
    732
    Man this speaks volumes about two countries, side by side. One with the ability to make rational choices and the other that needs to follow the herd of stupid, anyplace their handlers tell them to go. Here, in the states, I have been to hundreds of public school events, soccer games, baseball games etc. over a fifteen year period. I constantly was amazed at how many folks "needed" a double cab pickup or a Suburban to hall a kid or two around. Now it seems that the same idiots "downsized" to Grand Cherokees with Hemis and other dumb choices with 40% less space and the same shitty mileage. Meanwhile minivans are treated like they are something you have to driver if you can't afford $35K for an suv or giant truck?

    OTOH, We took a summer long trip a decade ago and spent a few weeks in western Canada. I began to notice that there was a huge difference in sensibility there. You apparently don't "need" a macho 4x4 family car if you live in snow country, 1000K north of our home, a minivan is just fine. Farmers and loggers drive macho trucks, families drive practical vehicles and don't give a shit what the neighbor thinks. In the last ten years the trend hasn't changed. This summer it was a trip to NB and NS. Not unusual to see a grocery store parking lot where the majority of the vehicles are minivans. The 90s and early 2000s fwd GM vans were very popular. Now it appears the Dodge has that market with a solid number of Toyota and Honda products out there. The OP is on the right track. A minivan is probably the most practical vehicle on the market today. I drive a full sized Chevy express Van as a work truck, but I wouldn't hesitate to buy another minivan for personal use.
    #9
  10. Tman66

    Tman66 Shawn's bro

    Joined:
    Jun 6, 2007
    Oddometer:
    9,624
    Location:
    Houston,Tx
    I've have had 2 Dodge Caravans. A 97 and 99. Both were very versatile vehicles.

    Only problems were the AC compressors.

    I hauled everything in those vans and pulled trailers with them as well.

    Never one hiccup engine/tranny wise.
    #10
  11. Queen

    Queen Long timer

    Joined:
    Sep 30, 2003
    Oddometer:
    24,492
    Location:
    Floriduh
    Had an '02 Caravan to haul the dogs around in and it was about the most comfortable vehicle for travel I've ever owned. Hauled a ton of crap in it, and it did just fine in most snowy crappy weather.
    #11
  12. McB

    McB Joe 40 ouncer

    Joined:
    Apr 8, 2005
    Oddometer:
    15,440
    Location:
    North Slope of the Flint Hills
    Had an '03 MPV that we bought new. Nice enough vehicle, but there was a nagging transmission software problem they never got fixed right. It would slam into 2nd or 3rd. When they finally got the 'correct' codes for the fix, it shifted like it was full of oatmeal. I assume that was a limited issue. Also had a '98 Odyssey with the 4 cyl. Sold it in '03 with almost 100k, and it's still being driven daily 8 years later. I'd buy it back today.

    Used minivans are underrated and undervalued. Everyone wanted SUVs, even if they were compacts or crossovers with essentially the same running gear as the minivans. Or they buy a compact pickup and load it up with bigger engines and crap so they get the same mileage as a full-size. There are some good deals out there in minivans compared to SUVs and trucks with similar age and miles.
    #12
  13. The PacRat

    The PacRat I'm that other guy

    Joined:
    Dec 13, 2007
    Oddometer:
    2,737
    Location:
    the Poison Oak Patch
    I guess the Caravan is shorter than the Grand Caravan? And both 2nd and 3rd row seats stow into the floor?
    #13
  14. jackd

    jackd Long timer

    Joined:
    Dec 9, 2006
    Oddometer:
    3,076
    Location:
    North Cowichan
    I've got a 2007 Caravan - the last year they built the shortie. No they don't come with stow-n-go seating. That seating only comes on the Grand Caravans. I really like my shortie Caravan -carries lots and drives quite nice. I actually prefer to drive it over my wife's 2010 Toyota RAV4. Nice wide track, good power, decent handling. I'm not so sure how well the follow on Dodge Journey stacks up against its earlier sibling. To date I have only had to put front brakes into it.
    #14
  15. Rogue_Ryder

    Rogue_Ryder 速 Flat Biller 速

    Joined:
    Dec 8, 2005
    Oddometer:
    7,751
    Location:
    Pinewood Springs, Colorado
    Toughest Mini-Van I've ever experienced was the Mazda MPV, my buddies mom traded in her Astro-Van that was falling apart for one back in like 1997, the AWD was incredible in that thing also. It did blow the tranny around 125K, but his dad had a junkyard one swapped in for a few hundred and used it up until a year or 2 ago on a Sales route no less!
    [​IMG]
    #15
  16. spagthorpe

    spagthorpe Long timer

    Joined:
    Aug 9, 2002
    Oddometer:
    14,796
    Location:
    San Diego
    Just like with trucks, I would go domestic with the minivan, if only because they are more comfortable. I don't know what it is, but Honda and Toyota _anything_ has uncomfortable ergos for me. The seats are horrible, and I think they all tend to put your ass below your knees which is tough to deal with except for short trips.
    #16
  17. California

    California Motorcyclist

    Joined:
    Nov 8, 2007
    Oddometer:
    3,066
    Location:
    Lantana, TX...after 56 years in Carmel Valley, Ca.
    Just a little note on the side,

    No small truck, nor any minivan get good fuel economy. They are aerodynamic bricks and much heavier than a small car. Weight and aero is what gas mileage is all about!

    If you get over 18mpg in town and over 22 on the highway, in any of them, consider yourself either very lucky or you drive like a little old lady.

    Just sayin............
    #17
  18. California

    California Motorcyclist

    Joined:
    Nov 8, 2007
    Oddometer:
    3,066
    Location:
    Lantana, TX...after 56 years in Carmel Valley, Ca.
    Just a little note on the side,

    No small truck, nor any minivan get good fuel economy. They are aerodynamic bricks and much heavier than a small car. Weight and aero is what gas mileage is all about!

    If you get over 18mpg in town and over 22 on the highway, in any of them, consider yourself either very lucky or you drive like a little old lady.

    Just sayin............
    #18
  19. Klay

    Klay dreaming adventurer

    Joined:
    Nov 19, 2005
    Oddometer:
    103,247
    Location:
    right here on my thermarest
    We got 24 mpg at 70 on the freeway with our 2006 T&C with the 3.8. The 2009 is delivering similar performance.
    #19
  20. Klay

    Klay dreaming adventurer

    Joined:
    Nov 19, 2005
    Oddometer:
    103,247
    Location:
    right here on my thermarest
    I think the Toyotas and Hondas are overpriced. We've gone through a series of Chrysler and Dodge minivans. They've fixed the transmissions. I could practically live in one of those things.
    #20