I can use the standard height screen on my Ultra with anything but a full face helmet. It does have the fairing "wings" or whatever the hell they are called but no fork winglets. I tried a shorty screen (like you I enjoy the wind) and hated it with all of my helmets. I then used a low screen that was laying around and it's perfect (for me) with any of my helmets. All three were Harley branded screens. May or may not work for you but just wanted to say the middle of what you tried so far is probably the sweet spot. Unless you like looking through the screen then go high.