Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'Parallel Universe' started by The Griz, Dec 4, 2008.
Which would you guys recommend? And Why?
I've heard the Zegas make a weird "clunking" sound. Probably the mounts are loose internally and the whole set up is prone to grenading at any time.
I've got the Varios on order, really just cause I needed something and had to put it in with the finance pool. Otherwise I'd seriously consider the Caribou set up. The Zegas would be about the last of the aluminum panniers I'd consider. Rather go with Metal Mule or Happy Trail (to cover the price spectrum).
I'll be interested to see how long it takes Dirt Bagz to come up with a mount---I traveled through Mexico and Guatemala with their soft bags and it was never a problem.
Got the 36L Caribous on some removable SW-Motech mounts myself. Linkee and Linkee. Very happy with them so far. The plastic cases won't get warped in a crash (though the SW-Motech mounts probably will), so they'll stay water tight and dust proof. They're lockable, narrower than the Zegas, but don't have that cool industrial look. De Gustibus non disputatum est.
Yeah, the Caribous look really good. Durable, watertight. And the mounting frame is TIG welded. Strong.
I do like the industrial look of bare aluminum, but the cost to effectiveness ratio of the Caribous is better I think. $770 for the whole setup right?
Does anyone have any experience with how those pelican cases hold up to the sunlight and heat?
The Caribous are rock solid. My buddy has had them on his DL1000 for years and swears by them. I had the Caribou rear case on my KLR and I'll be getting the sides on my GS when I can.
Sun, dirt, grime, they take whatever you can deal them.
while i was in high school (not so long ago, i'm 25) I worked at a dive shop and sold pelican cases. they're as durable as plastic cases can get, and totally waterproof. you can drive a small truck over them, throw them out of second story windows, etc.... being 16 and determined to test their claims, i can assure that they're telling the truth.
I have the Caribou's on my Vee and they are the best.
Moto-sport panniers has a mount that holds either their aluminum boxes or their aluminum backed Yukon II soft bags. Don' think they have a Dirt Bagz setup yet. I've got the Rangers (same mount as Dirt Bagz, slightly larger bag) on my DR-Z and love 'em.
I've heard that in a crash you will end up with a tin can vs a scrapped up pelican. The aluminum ones do not crash well at all because they will get dented and trying to remove the dent then only makes things worst. So unless you are 110% sure that the bike won't go down then the pelicans are the better choice. Plus, price wise you get to save a couple hundred or more, which of course means more money to farkle the bike in other ways.
Not on your list, but the Happy Trails are great on my 800.
The pictures on their website doesn't do them justice.
They were in stock, where as the other brands were back ordered forever.
At $700, you can buy a lot of other goodies over the TT's.
Thanks, everyone. I'm leaning towards the Caribous I think. Good point that if you go down, you get scraped plastic instead of dented or cracked aluminum. My buddy has Happy Trails panniers on his KLR. He went down once (not very hard) and they cracked along the corners. The design flaw of the Happy Trails is that they are welded along the corners. TT Zega cases are one entire piece of aluminum with rounded corners. No welds. So they only dent, which you can pound out with a good sized rock. But for me the TT Zegas are too expensive.
Spoof is funny!
Gotta go with the Caribous. I haven't heard anything good about many aluminum cases fairing well after a get-off and Pelicans are pretty hard-core. I've been using 'em on the job for years (US Navy).
You can say that again!
I just put a full set of carabou cases on my f800gs and it is a great set up looks good n tuff.
PICS! Good grief man!
Yeah, I'm pretty much dead set on the Caribous now. Been riding my new F800GS a lot even though it's been cold as hell (highs of 20 degrees F). But now it's snowing.... This bike rides like a dream though!
Have you thought about Jesse bags? They're pricey, but they fit close to the bike and, from what I've heard, hold up well.
Thanks, man. I'll check 'em out.