I posted some questions about a short windscreen a couple pages back. I ended up getting the Givi. While I hate the black finish, at least on my black motorcycle, it works as I had hoped, at this point. Brings the air over the screen a little lower so I get more air flow to the top and middle of my helmet but doesn't bring it so low that the wind is hitting under my helmet making things loud. Only tried it with my XD4 and the peak vibration is less than with the OEM screen. I will probably wear my RF-1200 tomorrow going to work and see how that helmet reacts to the lower airflow. I am am 5'9" FWIW.